State Circle
Friday, November 13, 2026
Season 2026 Episode 43 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Maryland’s fiscal future; recording consent laws in MD; plus, the rise of on-call grandmas.
How will the newly re-elected Governor and Maryland lawmakers solve the multi billion dollar budget deficit facing the state next year? Plus, recording consent law - how it applies in Maryland. And find out how on-call grandmas are helping families.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
State Circle is a local public television program presented by MPT
State Circle is made possible by the generous support of viewers like you.
State Circle
Friday, November 13, 2026
Season 2026 Episode 43 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
How will the newly re-elected Governor and Maryland lawmakers solve the multi billion dollar budget deficit facing the state next year? Plus, recording consent law - how it applies in Maryland. And find out how on-call grandmas are helping families.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch State Circle
State Circle is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipTHIS PROGRAM IS MADE BY MPT TO ENRICH THE DIVERSE COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT OUR STATE AND IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF OUR MEMBERS.
THANK YOU.
CLOSED CAPTIONING HAS BEEN MADE POSSIBLE IN PART BY MARYLAND RELAY, EMPOWERING THOSE WHO ARE DEAF, HARD OF HEARING OR SPEECH DISABLED TO STAY CONNECTED BY PHONE.
[♪♪] CONNECTING MARYLANDERS TO THEIR GOVERNMENT, THIS IS "STATE CIRCLE".
>> Jeff: WELCOME TO "STATE CIRCLE".
FOR MARYLAND'S NEWLY REELECTED GOVERNOR AND LEGISLATORS THE CAMPAIGN MAY HAVE BEEN THE EASY PART.
NOW, THEY WILL HAVE TO SOLVE A MULTIBILLION DOLLAR BUDGET DEFICIT CONSTRAINED BY A SLOW GROWING ECONOMY.
OUR NEWSMAKER Dr.
DARAIUS IRANI CHIEF ECONOMIST OF THE REGIONAL ECONOMIC STUDIES INSTITUTE AT TOWSON UNIVERSITY.
THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
>> Jeff: I WAS PLEASED TO BE IN THE AUDIENCE FOR THE PRESENTATION ON THE ECONOMIC OUTLOOK FOR THE YEAR AHEAD.
GIVE US THE SYNOPSIS OF THAT?
>> THE ONGOING WAR IN IRAN HAS IS PUTTING PRESSURE ON PETROLEUM PRICES EVERYTHING FROM GAS, DIESEL PUSHED UP OR KEPT ELEVATED.
WE'VE GOT THE TARIFFS WHICH WILL PUT PRESSURE ON PRICES FOR HOUSEHOLDS.
WE'VE GOT INFLATION COMING UP AS A RESULT OF ALL OF THE THINGS GOING ON WITH THE TARIFFS AND THE WAR IN IRAN PUTTING PRESSURE ON HOUSEHOLDS AND THEIR DECISIONS.
IT'S WHAT I WOULD CALL A RATHER CHALLENGING ECONOMY FOR HOUSEHOLDS GOING IN AND THEY MAKEUP 70% OF THE ECONOMY.
IF THEY FEEL HURT THE ECONOMY MAY START TO FEEL PAINS.
>> Jeff: A PERFECT LEAD IN FOR THE FIRST SLIDE IN YOUR SLIDE DECK.
EXTENSIVE IT IS AVAILABLE ON-LINE SOMEWHERE I'M SURE.
THE WEBSITE.
BUT THIS ONE CAUGHT MY EYE.
CONSUMER SENT.
HOW CONSUMERS ARE FEELING ABOUT THE WORLD AND TOWARDS THE END HERE, ON THE VERY RIGHT THAT LOW NUMBER IS HOW CONSUMERS ARE FEELING TODAY.
AND THIS IS WHY THE REPUBLICANS GOT SPHARPBED IN THE ELECT SMASHED IN THE ELECTION BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE NOT HAPPY.
>> YOU CAN SEE THERE WERE CERTAINLY ONE OTHER LOW POINT IN JULY OF 2022 WHERE INFLATION AND GAS PRICES WERE AT THEIR PEAK.
HOUSEHOLDS MAKE DECISIONS, AS A RESULT OF THE ELEVATED FUEL PRICES, ELEVATED INTEREST RATES, ELEVATED FOOD PRICES HOUSEHOLDS DECIDED THAT THE INDIVIDUALS IN CHARGE WERE NOT DOING A GOOD JOB AND IT'S REFLECTED IN THE CONSUMER SENTIMENT WHICH LOOKS AT FUTURE EXPECTATIONS.
AND HOUSEHOLDS FEEL UNCERTAIN IN OCTOBER THEY WEREN'T HAPPY.
>> Jeff: ONE OF THE REASONS OF THE UNCERTAINTY HOUSING COSTS THAT IS THE NEXT SLIDE.
AND THERE IS A DIVERGENCE BETWEEN WHAT HOUSING COSTS AND HOW MUCH MONEY PEOPLE HAVE AVAILABLE TO PAY FOR IT.
IT LOOKS LIKE FIVE YEARS AGO THINGS CHANGED.
>> THE RED LINE IS YOUR MEDIAN INCOME IN THE REGION OF THE U.S.
THE DASHED BLUE LINE IS THE INCOME NEEDED TO BUY THE MEDIAN HOME IN THE U.S.
WITH A 10% DOWN AND YOU CAN SEE 2021 THE LINES CROSSED RESULTING IN THAT MANY INDIVIDUALS WERE COULD NOT AFFORD THE HOMES IN THE AREA.
AND AS A RESULT, WE'RE SEEING BASICALLY AVERAGE AGE OF THE HOMEOWNER IN 2020 WAS 30.
IT IS NOW TRANSFORMED TO 40.
NOW THE AVERAGE HOMEOWNER IS 40 YEARS OLD BEFORE THEY BUY THEIR FIRST HOME.
>> Jeff: AND IT'S HARD TO GET IN BECAUSE YOU HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT SELLING BECAUSE THEY ARE SITTING ON A 3% MORTGAGE AND SO THE MARKET IS FROZEN AND THEN THE SUPPLY QUESTION ARE WE NOT BUILDING ENOUGH HOUSES?
>> WE ARE UNDER BUILDING HOUSES WE ARE FOUR MILLION SHORT IN THE U.S., 100,000 HERE IN MARYLAND.
WE ARE NOT BUILDING HOMES FAST ENOUGH.
MUCH OF THE ZONING IN MANY STATES INCLUDING MARYLAND IS GEARED FOR LOW DENSITY ZONING WHICH DOESN'T MEAN YOU AVOID DENSITY WHICH MEANS THAT LAND IS SCARCE IT'S NOT MAKING ANYMORE AND AS A RESULT FEWER HOUSES ARE BEING BUILT.
TO YOUR POINT MANY HOUSEHOLDS ARE SITTING ON THE 2.5% MORTGAGE NOT SELLING SO THE SUPPLY ON THE EXISTING HOMES IS NOT GOING UP.
NEW CONSTRUCTION FELL THE COST OF NEW HOME CONSTRUCTION IS DRIVEN BY TARIFFS BECAUSE MANY OF OUR IMPORTED ITEMS LUMBER, HVAC SYSTEMS COME TOGETHER AT THE HOME SITE THOSE HAVE GONE UP NOT MANY HOME BUILDERS ARE BUILDING AS MANY HOMES.
>> Jeff: LET'S TALK JOBS.
NATIONALLY THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE AND THE MARYLAND RATE ARE SIMILAR AROUND 4% UNEMPLOYED.
WHERE ARE THE SO THIS IS WHERE THE JOBS ARE.
GOVERNMENT LEADING THE LIST.
TRADE TRANSPORTATION AND UTILITIES, HEALTHCARE AND SOCIAL ASSISTANCE.
LEISURE, HOSPITALITY RETAIL THIS IS WHAT IS IMPORTANT HERE AND YOU FREQUENTLY SUM IT UP AS HEADS AND BEDS.
>> IT'S BEDS, MEDS, FEDS AND TRENDS.
>> YOUR SEX -- SOMETHING FOR IS IMPORTANT.
>> THOSE JOBS ACCOUNT FOR 38% OF ALL JOBS IN MARYLAND.
THOSE FIVE SECTORS DRIVE MARYLAND.
UNFORTUNATELY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT POLICIES HAVE IMPACTED ALL OF THOSE EVERYTHING FROM THE DOGE CUTBACKS IMPACTED OUR FEDERAL EMPLOYMENT.
>> Jeff: 30,000 PEOPLE.
>> 30,000 PEOPLE LOST THEIR JOBS IN MARYLAND.
HUGE, HUGE CHALLENGE.
TARIFFS IMPACTED THE PORT.
WE'VE SEEN A DECLINE IN TOURISM 4% THE REST OF THE WORLD INCREASED BY 10%.
MEDS THE MEDICAL SPENDING RESEARCH AND NIH HAVE SEEN CUTBACKS AND WE'VE SEEN CUT BACKS TO EDUCATION.
>> Jeff: THERE ARE NONETHELESS THERE ARE JOB OPENINGS LET'S LOOK AT WHERE THE OPENINGS ARE IN MARYLAND AND HERE WE GO.
HEALTH NUMBER ONE BY FAR AND RIGHT BEHIND IT COMPUTER STUFF.
>> RIGHT.
SO, AGAIN, THIS IS A SIGN IF I SHOW THIS SIGN IN 10 YEARS AGO PRECOVID IT WOULD BE THE SAME.
HEALTH IS ALWAYS VERY WHERE WE ARE FACING SERIOUS SHORTAGES.
AND AGAIN WE ARE GETTING OLDER AS A SOCIETY WE NEED MORE ASSISTANCE IN OUR LIVING AND WE DO NEED MORE PHYSICAL REHAB WE ARE LIVING LONGER WHICH MEANS WE THINK WE ARE STRONGER AND FASTER AND THOSE ARE NOT NECESSARILY THE SAME.
WE ARE FACING CHALLENGES WE HAVE MORE TELEHEALTH PROGRAMMING.
MUCH OF OUR WORK IS ON-LINE.
ZOOM ALL THOSE THINGS REQUIRE MUCH MORE SUPPORT FROM THE COMPUTER SIDE WHICH AGAIN SHOWS THAT SIDE.
AGAIN WE'RE ALL GETTING FATTER FINGERS AND IT'S HARDER TO PUSH THE BUTTONS.
>> Jeff: PEOPLE MIGHT WONDER WHY THE PICTURE OF PETER SELLERS?
>> I CHARACTERIZE THE INSPECTOR ECONOMY BECAUSE WE HAVE DONE SELF-INFLICTED WOUNDS FROM THE WAR IN IRAN AND TARIFFS AND THE ECONOMY SEEMS TO CHUG ALONG.
>> Jeff: AND IT IS A MYSTERY.
>> YES.
>> Jeff: WILL NOT BE SOLVED BY THE INSPECTOR.
CAN IT BE SOLVED BY OUR REPRESENTATIVES IN ANNAPOLIS WHO COME BACK INTO SESSION IN JANUARY THEY HAVE A BIG FORECAST DEFICIT AND WE DO HAVE A SLOW GROWING ECONOMY HERE.
WHAT WOULD YOU ADVISE.
>> ONE OF THE THINGS I WOULD ADVISE IS THINKING ABOUT WHAT IS CAUSING PEOPLE TO LEAVE.
THE HIGH COST IN MARYLAND WE'RE SEEING YOUNGER INDIVIDUALS LEAVE WHEREAS BEFORE IT USED TO BE THE 55 AND OVER WOULD MIGRATE TO FLORIDA.
NOT YOUNG PEOPLE ARE MOVING BECAUSE THEY CANNOT AFFORD TO BUY A HOUSE HERE IN MARYLAND.
ADDRESSING AT FORWARDABILITY ISSUE EVERYTHING FROM MAKING SURE THAT IT DOESN'T TAKE THREE OR FOUR MONTHS TO BUILD A HOME IN MARYLAND.
THAT SEEMS TO BE THE HOLD-UP AND THAT CAUSES THE COST OF HOMES TO BE HIGHER.
NUMBER ONE.
THE OTHER TWO IS CLEARING OUT SOME OF THE REGULATION I LIKE TO SAY IN MARYLAND YOU CAN HERE IN MARYLAND YOU CAN DREAM IT WE CAN TAX IT AND REGULATE AND PERMIT IT.
AND THOSE ARE CHALLENGES FOR A THRIVING ECONOMY.
>> Jeff: WAS IT YOU WHO REFERRED TO THE PERMITTING PROCESSES SMITH ISLAND INDICATION.
>> I WILL SAY THAT I GAVE CREDIT TO BEN SIEGEL WHO CHARACTERIZED THE HOME BUILDING PROCESS THE REGULATIONS THE SMITH ISLAND CASE EACH LAYER DELICIOUS AND IMPORTANT LAYERED ON IT'S DENSE AND MAKES IT DIFFICULT TO MOVE NIMBLELY.
>> Jeff: YOU MENTIONED THE BASEMENT.
I THINK OF THE BASEMENT WHERE THE BALTIMORE RAVENS STAND IN THEIR DIVISION STANDINGS BUT YOU HAD ANOTHER BASEMENT IN MIND.
>> TALKING ABOUT THE CURRENCY.
WHO SAID THE BASEMENT?
MAYBE IT WAS ME TO GET THAT JOKE IN.
>> MAYBE YOU DID.
ONE L.
>> Jeff: -- >> Jeff: WE'RE HEARING A SALES TAX INCREASE.
YOU HAVE POINTED OUT I DO NOT BELIEVE I'M MAKING THIS UP WE ARE A SMALL STATE.
>> GEOGRAPHY DOESN'T LIE.
SO WE'RE A SMALL STATE IF WE WERE TO UNLIKE SOME OF THE OTHER STATES IN THE MIDWEST OR IN THE SOUTH, THEY RAISED SALES TAXES AND THEY'VE FINANCED THEIR GOVERNMENT THROUGH SALES TAX CONSUMPTION TAX MARYLAND IS CHALLENGED BECAUSE WE ARE A SMALL STATE WHICH MEANS WE RAISE OUR SALES TAX HIGHER THAN VIRGINIA OR DELAWARE OR NEW JERSEY PEOPLE WILL DRIVE THERE TO BUY THINGS.
SO IT BECOMES A CHALLENGE HOW MUCH CAN WE RAISE SALES TAX ENOUGH TO OFFSET THE COST OF GASOLINE.
THE FACT THAT GASOLINE IS $3 AND CHANGE MIGHT CHANGE THAT NUMBER.
DRIVING 20-30 MILES TO SAVE A DOLLAR, MAY NOT BE THE SMART MOVE.
>> Jeff: YOUR THOUGHTS ON A.I.
AND DATA CENTERS AND ALL THAT?
THE IDEA WITH A.I.
IS IT'S GOING TO IMPROVE PRODUCTIVITY BUT IS IT GOING TO IMPROVE TO THE POINT THAT NONE OF US HAVE JOBS ANYMORE.
>> THERE ARE CERTAIN SECTORS I DON'T WANT TO DIMINISH A.I.
'S IMPACT AND SAY THIS IS GOING TO SOLVE EVERYTHING WE WILL BE SITTING AT HOME WATCHING TV AS A.I.
DOES OUR JOBS.
THE HYPE OF A.I.
IS IT CAN DO CERTAIN THINGS AND IT FREES UP INDIVIDUALS TO DO THINGS THAT ARE HIGHER ORDER.
A.I.
CAN DO MANY THINGS.
IN THE CREATIVE ARTS A.I.
IS CAN CERTAINLY CREATE VIDEOS BUT THEY LOOK FAKE.
THEY LOOK ARTIFICIAL.
WE'LL NEED HUMAN HANDS IN THERE.
A.I.
IS GREAT FOR PROGRAMMING.
BUT IT CAN'T DEBUG A PROGRAM.
SO THE CHALLENGE BECOMES YOU CAN WRITE A PROGRAM BUT IF THE PROGRAM GOES OFF THE RAILS, THEN IT NEEDS SOMEONE TO GO LET'S FIX THIS PROGRAM.
THERE ARE THINGS IT CAN DO.
IN TERMS OF THE LARGE DATA CENTERS THEY ARE HUGE POWER CENTERS A LOT OF WATER THERE ARE SOME JOBS THAT ARE CREATED, BUT WE'RE NOT TALKING BIG NUMBERS OF JOBS.
>> Jeff: THE STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ARE SUPPORTING SUBSIDIZING BIG NEW PROJECTS.
THERE'S THE MILITARY SHIPYARD INTO THE SPARROW'S POINT AREA.
THE SPHERE THE VEGAS ATTRACTION THEY ARE BUILDING A MINI VERSION FROM NATIONAL HARBOR.
DO THOSE THINGS GENERALLY MAKE SENSE?
HARBORPLACE IT WILL TAKE HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND WE WILL HAVE THIS BIG SHINEY NEW THING THAT WILL EMPLOY PEOPLE?
>> THOSE ARE OFTENTIMES TRICKY THINGS BECAUSE THE END OF THE DAY YOU DON'T KNOW.
THINKING ABOUT FOXCONN AND THE FIRST TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IT WAS TOUTED AS THE NEXT BIG THING AND IT NEVER HAPPENED.
I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS IS IF NOTHING HAPPENS NO ONE GETS PAID OR NO TAX CREDIT.
THE SPARROW'S POINT IS A GREAT OPPORTUNITY 3,000 PLUS INDIVIDUALS EMPLOYED.
SEVERAL THOUSAND MORE IN TERMS OF CONSTRUCTION IT WILL BE A BIG OPPORTUNITY FOR THE COUNTY AS WELL AS THE STATE.
THE SPHERE AN OPPORTUNITY TO CREATE MORE OF AN ATTRACTION IN THAT AREA, NATIONAL HARBOR.
AGAIN THE NICE THING ABOUT NATIONAL HARBOR IS DRAWS PEOPLE FROM VIRGINIA AND DC THEY SPEND THEIR MONEY NOT ONLY IN THE NATIONAL HARBOR BUT ALSO IN THE MGM GRAND CASINO WHICH IS GOOD.
ANYTHING THAT CAN ATTRACT MORE PEOPLE IS GREAT.
HARBORPLACE, RIGHT NOW, WE'VE GOT A HALF EMPTY OLD FACILITY IT LOOKS VERY DECREPIT NOT A GOOD IMAGE FOR THE CITY TO HAVE WHICH IS STRUGGLING WITH ITS OWN IMAGE ANYWAYS BUT TO HAVE A DECREPIT SET OF BUILDINGS UNDERUTILIZED VACANT ON PRIME REAL ESTATE IS A REAL CONCERN.
SO I THINK THERE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO REBUILD THE AREA.
>> Jeff: BUT TO SUM UP WHEN WE THINK ABOUT ALL THESE TRENDS AND APPLY THEM TO BEDS, MEDS AND TREADS, THINGS IN OUR NEW A.I.
DRIVEN ECONOMY LOOK GOOD LIKE THE PORT SEEMS TO BE LIKE AN INCREASINGLY VALUABLE ASSET GOING FORWARD.
>> WE ARE A NATION THAT 70% OF THE ECONOMY RUNS ON HOUSEHOLD DECISIONS.
WE SEE IT AND WANT IT AND BUY IT.
THAT IS DRIVING THE LOGISTICS HERE IN MARYLAND THE GROWTH OF AMAZON IT'S IMPORTANT PHYSICAL GOODS ARE IMPORTANT.
MANUFACTURING GOODS ARE IMPORTANT IT MAYBE THE CASE THESE ARE DRONED SUBMARINES OR DRONED THAT'S FINE BUT SOMEONE NEEDS TO BUILT IT.
>> Jeff: DARAIUS IRANI TOWSON UNIVERSITY THE REGIONAL ECONOMICS INSTITUTE WHERE YOU CAN FIND MORE INFORMATION.
SIR, THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU.
>> Jeff: NOW WHAT IS A PARENT TO DO WHEN THEY NEED HELP BUT DON'T HAVE FAMILY MEMBERS NEARBY AS NANCY YAMADA REPORTS, THEY ARE HIRING ON CALL GRANDMAS.
>> I'M RETIRED I USED TO TAKE CARE OF MY GRANDSON THEY MOVED OUT OF THE AREA AND I LOVE BEING AROUND KIDS AND FEELING LIKE I CAN HELP OUT FAMILIES.
>> SUE STILL GETS TO BE A HANDS ON GRANDMA BUT TO OTHER PEOPLE'S KIDS ON THIS DAY FIVE-YEAR-OLD OF MONROVIA SHE IS ONE OF THE CAREGIVERS FOR ON CALL GRANDMA A SERVICE CONNECTING OLDER RETIREES WITH FAMILIES WHO NEEDED HANDS IN FREDERICK.
>> I DO EVERYTHING FROM WAKING CHILDREN UP, GETTING THEM READY FOR SCHOOL, BREAKFAST, WALKING THEM TO THE BUS STOP.
GET TO PLAY WITH BABIES WHEN MOMS ARE AT HOME ON ZOOM CALLS.
>> ON CALL GRAND MA OPENED THIS YEAR AFTER MINDY SAW KIDS WALKING HOME FROM SCHOOL.
>> WALKING WITH CAREGIVERS AND PARENTS AND IT BROUGHT ME BACK TO THE DAYS WHEN I WALKED MY KIDS TO SCHOOL I THOUGHT I CAN BE AN ON CALL GRANDMA FOR ONE OF THESE FAMILIES IF THEY NEEDED SOMEONE.
AND I DISMISSED THE IDEA AND YEARS LATER I WAS IN A CAREGIVING ROLE INSTEAD OF JUST ONE PERSON, I CAN CREATE A NETWORK OF PEOPLE AND WE CAN HELP MANY FAMILIES.
>> TODAY THERE ARE 17 FULLY VETTED ON CALL GRANDMAS PROVIDING 100 PLUS CARE TAKING HOURS A WEEK IN THE COMMUNITY.
THE JOB HAS PERKS.
>> THEY HAVE THE FLEXIBILITY MANY ARE RETIRED LOOKING FOR SOMETHING MEANINGFUL PART-TIME TO DO.
THIS FILLS THE PERFECT FOR THEM BECAUSE THEY CAN TAKE A JOB IF THEY WANT IT IF THEY DON'T HAVE TIME THEY CAN SAY NO.
>> THE MOM ROTATES BETWEEN THREE ON CALL GRANDMAS.
>> HE LOVES THEM I TELL HIM THE NIGHT BEFORE WHO IS COMING AND HE IS SO EXCITED.
>> IT IS A WIN-WIN FOR THE FAMILY AND THE CARETAKERS THAT HAVE THE HEART AND TIME TO GIVE.
>> IT'S THE BEST BUSINESS MODEL EVER.
I'VE TALKED TO PEOPLE AND TOLD THEM WHO IS COMING THAT ON CALL GRANDMAS IS COMING AND THEY ARE LIKE WHAT IS THAT?
IT IS THE COOLEST MODEL AND PEOPLE MAYBE THE KIDS ARE IN DIFFERENT PHASES OF THEIR LIVES IT'S SUPER AMAZING FOR THEM TO HAVE TIME WITH A CHILD THAT ISN'T RELATED TO THEM BECAUSE MAYBE THEIR FAMILY IS FURTHER AWAY.
>> EARNING EXTRA MONEY IS NICE NOT THE MAIN MOTIVATOR.
>> I LOVE EVERY SECOND.
IT'S ALWAYS THE CHALLENGE I LIKE KIDS AND I LIKE TO WATCH THEM GROW AND IT'S FUN.
>> I'M NANCY YAMADA FOR "STATE CIRCLE".
>> Jeff: AFTER A RECENT CONFRONTATION BETWEEN CONGRESSMAN ANDY ELLIS AND A STUDENT REPORTER MEDIA GROUPS CRITICIZED HIS ASSERTION SHE COULD BE PROSECUTED FOR RECORDING HIS PRESS EVENT.
ON A RECENT "DIRECT CONNECTION" PROGRAM WE SPOKE WITH ATTORNEY JOYCE SMITHEY ABOUT MARYLAND'S TWO PARTY CONSENT RECORDING LAW WHICH COULD BE RECONSIDERED IN THE NEXT GENERAL ASSEMBLY SESSION.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US AND THE TWO PARTY CONSENT THING I GUESS MEANS YOU CAN'T RECORD SOMEBODY WITHOUT THEIR KNOWLEDGE OR PERMISSION, RIGHT?
>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME, JEFF.
AND YOU ARE CLOSE.
FIRST OF ALL TWO PARTY ISN'T EVEN CORRECT IT'S ALL PARTY CONSENT.
AND GENERALLY YOU NEED CONSENT.
THERE ARE EXCEPTIONS AND IT'S ALL ABOUT PRIVATE CONVERSATIONS THAT CAN'T BE RECORDED NOT ALL CONVERSATIONS.
>> Jeff: HOW DOES THIS COME UP IN YOUR LAW PRACTICE WHICH IS MOSTLY FOCUSED ON EMPLOYMENT MATTERS?
>> GOODNESS, ALL THE TIME.
PEOPLE RECORD THEIR BOSS FOR EXAMPLE DURING A PERFORMANCE REVIEW THINKING THEY ARE CAPTURING EVIDENCE THAT MIGHT BE HELPFUL TO A CASE LATER.
OR THEY HAVE A BOSS YELLING ACROSS A CROWDED WORKPLACE SCREAMING AT THEM AND THEY ARE RECORDING THAT.
AND THE REALITY IS THAT IN MARYLAND, ARE YOU NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO USE THAT IN A CASE.
NOT ONLY DOES THE MARYLAND WIRETAP STATUTE SAY YOU CANNOT USE IT AS EVIDENCE BUT IT COMES AT RISK OF PROSECUTION BECAUSE THERE IS A CRIMINAL COMPONENT TO OUR WIRETAP STATUTE AND PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE IT IS A FIVE-YEAR FELONY IN MARYLAND TO DO THAT.
>> Jeff: HAVE YOU EVER SEEN THAT PROSECUTED?
>> NOT PERSONALLY OTHER THAN WATCHING WITH EAGER INTEREST IN THE LINDA TRIP PROSECUTION.
YOU DON'T SEE IT AS A CRIME THAT IS OFTEN PIQUING THE INTEREST OF PROSECUTORS IN MARYLAND.
>> Jeff: NOT TO SPEND TOO MUCH TIME ON THE CONGRESSMAN HARRIS SITUATION AFTER A DEBATE ON THE EASTERN SHORE HE GATHERED A NUMBER OF REPORTERS ON THE SIDE FOR A GAGGLE ALL THE REPORTERS SEEMED THEIR PHONES OUT.
I'M GUESSING THERE WOULD BE NO EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY WHEN YOU ARE TALKING TO REPORTER WITH THEIR PHONES OUT?
>> THAT'S EXACTLY RIGHT.
THE PRESS CONFERENCE IS THE DEFINITION OF WHERE YOU DON'T EXPECT A REASONABLE RIGHT TO PRIVACY THERE.
AND EVEN MOREOVER WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE VIDEO OF THAT YOU SEE EVERY OTHER REPORTER WITH A RECORDING DEVICE IN FRONT OF HIM.
HE IS NOT OBJECTING TO THE OTHER REPORTERS.
IT'S JUST NOT REASONABLE TO SAY THAT THAT IS A PLACE WHERE YOU HAVE A REASONABLE EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY.
>> Jeff: ALL RIGHT SO FOR THE BENEFIT OF OUR VIEWERS WHAT ADVICE DO YOU GIVE YOUR CLIENTS, MAYBE SOMEBODY WHO IS IN SOME SORT OF WORKPLACE DISPUTE WHAT CAN YOU DO, WHAT CAN YOU NOT DO?
>> A GREAT QUESTION.
GET CONSENT.
AND REMEMBER THAT NOTICE DOES NOT EQUAL CONSENT THAT COMES UP WITH THE NEW TECHNOLOGY.
HEY, THERE WAS A PHONE IN FRONT OF YOU IN A PRIVATE CONVERSATION OR SOMEONE IS WEARING META GLASSES YOU SHOULD HAVE BEEN ON NOTICE THAT IS STILL NOT CONSENT.
WHEN YOU PICK UP THE PHONE AND SAYS THIS MAYBE RECORDED GET CONSENT ANYTIME YOU ARE GOING TO CAPTURE AUDIO WHERE ONE OF THE PARTIES IS SITTING IN MARYLAND THAT'S MY ADVICE.
>> Jeff: I GET THE THIS MAYBE RECORDED, EVERYDAY.
I CALLED TO SCHEDULE AN OIL CHANGE AND THIS MESSAGE CONVERSATION MAYBE RECORDED FOR CUSTOMER SERVICE PURPOSES.
IS THAT ALL THEY NEED?
>> YOU KNOW THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION IN THE SENSE THAT I THINK EACH AND EVERY TIME YOU DO THAT, THE QUESTION WILL BECOME IF SOMEONE KNOWS THEY ARE GETTING RECORDED AND CONTINUES THE CONVERSATION IS THAT ENOUGH TO ESTABLISH CONSENT?
THERE ISN'T A LOT OF CASE LAW ON THAT.
AND I THINK IT WILL BE FACT-DRIVEN AND TECHNOLOGY-DRIVEN HOW WAS THAT AUDIO CAPTURED.
SO EVERY TIME YOU ARE IN THAT SITUATION IS IT POSSIBLE THAT NOTICE COULD TURN INTO CONSENT WHEN YOU CONTINUE WITH THE PRIVATE CONVERSATION?
MAYBE.
YOU KNOW, AGAIN, THE COURT WOULD LOOK AT ALL THE FACTS AND THE TECHNOLOGY BUT IT'S NEVER CERTAIN.
>> Jeff: JOYCE, OTHER STATES, MOST OF THE OTHER STATES DON'T DO IT THE WAY MARYLAND DOES.
THERE'S A GROUP OF 12, I BELIEVE.
>> YOU'VE DONE YOUR RESEARCH THAT IS THE EXACT NUMBER.
AND IN FACT, IT'S WILD TO TALK TO PEOPLE WHO MIGHT FOLLOW COURT TV IN CALIFORNIA WHERE IT IS ADMISSIBLE NOT ONLY IT'S NOT A FELONY IN CALIFORNIA BUT IF YOU RECORD YOUR BOSS YELLING AT YOU YOU CAN USE IT IN YOUR CASE.
WHEREAS HERE IF YOU DO THAT YOU WILL HAVE TO ASSERT THE FIFTH AMENDMENT WHEN YOU GET QUESTIONED ON THAT.
YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT THAT OTHER STATES AREN'T SIMILAR TO MARYLAND AND IT IS A MINORITY JURISDICTION IN REQUIRING ALL PARTY CONSENT.
>> Jeff: THE LEGISLATURE PERIODICALLY LOOKS AT REPEALING OR UPDATING THIS LAW AND AS YOU SAY, THERE MAYBE GRAY AREAS.
ARE THERE ANY CHANGES THAT YOU THINK WOULD MAKE SENSE?
>> IT'S HARD TO SAY WITH TECHNOLOGY CHANGING EVERY SINGLE DAY.
I MEAN THESE A.I.
TRANSCRIPTION THINGS THAT DIDN'T EXIST A COUPLE YEARS AGO AND BY THE TIME WE GET AROUND TO ADAPTING THE LAW TO ADDRESS WHAT YOUR EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY IS WITH REGARD TO THESE TRANSCRIPTION SERVICES IT WILL BE DIFFERENT IN A YEAR.
SO I DO THINK THAT THE LAW NEEDS TO BE DEVELOPED TO ADDRESS THINGS LIKE META GLASSES, TRANSCRIPTION, A.I., THAT IS NOW THIS YEAR'S VERSION OF HOLDING A CAMERA IN-YOUR-FACE.
I THINK THEY WILL HAVE TO ADAPT THE LAW TO ADDRESS TECHNOLOGY.
I THINK THE COURTS ARE SOON TO GET CASES ABOUT THAT AND THEY WILL START SHAPING THAT AS WELL.
I THINK YOU WILL SEE DEVELOPMENTS IN ALL OF THE STATES THAT HAVE THE ALL PARTY CONSENT LAWS.
>> Jeff: ARE PHONE CALLS ANY DIFFERENT?
IT USED TO BE YEARS AGO AT A RADIO STATION I WORKED THERE WAS A CERTAIN LINE YOU COULD RECORD AUDIO AND IT TRANSMITTED A BEEP THIS MAY HAVE BEEN AN F.C.C.
RULE EVERY FIVE SECONDS THE BEEP DID NOT GO IN THE RECORDING BUT THE OTHER PARTY HEARD BEEP AND FROM THAT THEY SHOULD HAVE UNDERSTOOD THEY WERE BEING RECORDED.
>> I SORT OF REMEMBER THIS CALLING INTO RADIO STATIONS WHEN I WAS A TEENAGER TO WIN CONCERT TICKETS I REMEMBER SOMETHING ABOUT THAT.
TELEPHONE ISN'T DIFFERENT.
IT'S THE CAPTURE OF AUDIO BY ELECTRONIC MEANS AND RECORDING IT.
SO IF YOU ARE RECORDING SOMEBODY VIA TELEPHONE AND ONE OF THE PARTIES IN MARYLAND IS IN MARYLAND YOU ARE GOING TO INVOKE THAT MARYLAND WIRETAP LAW THAT AGAIN NOT JUST HAS THE CIVIL PENALTIES I BELIEVE IT'S $1,000 CIVILLY BUT A FIVE-YEAR FELONY IN MARYLAND TONIGHT WILL GET IMPLICATED ON THE TELEPHONE CALL.
>> Jeff: ARE THERE OTHER AREAS OF LAW THAT YOU COME ACROSS THAT ARE SO DIFFERENT BETWEEN STATES?
I THINK IF I GO DOWN THE ROAD TO DC, THEY DON'T HAVE THIS, RIGHT?
SO THAT IS ANOTHER QUESTION.
COULD A MARYLANDER IN A EMPLOYMENT DISPUTE DRIVE TO WASHINGTON TO PLACE THE PHONE CALL THAT THEY SECRETLY RECORD?
NOT ADVISING THAT, BY THE WAY.
>> THAT IS A GREAT DISCLAIMER.
I'VE HAD CALLS FROM PEOPLE WHO HAVE DONE SOMETHING LIKE BUT THE PROBLEM IS THAT ANY PARTY IN MARYLAND WILL INVOKE THE RAMIFICATIONS OF THE WIRETAP ACT.
YOU HAVE TO NOT ONLY BE IN DC BUT YOU HAVE TO HOPE THE BOSS YOU WANT TO RECORD TRAVELED OUTSIDE OF MARYLAND AS WELL.
BUT WE DID HAVE A CASE WHERE THAT HAPPENED AND THE PERSON HAD A GREAT RECORDING IN A SEX HARASSMENT CASE AND WE WERE ABLE TO USE IT IN A MARYLAND COURT BECAUSE NONE OF THE PARTIES WERE IN MARYLAND AT THE TIME IT WAS RECORDED AND THEREFORE THAT WIRETAP STATUTE DIDN'T APPLY AND WE WERE ABLE TO GET IT ADMITTED.
>> Jeff: THANKS TO ATTORNEY JOYCE SMITHEY AND THAT IS "STATE CIRCLE" FOR THIS WEEK.
JOIN US EVERY WEEK AS WE CONNECT MARYLANDERS TO THEIR GOVERNMENT.
VIDEOS OF OUR PROGRAMS CAN BE FOUND AT VIDEO.MPT.TV AND THROUGH THE FREE PBS APP.
WE ARE ALSO ON SOCIAL MEDIA AT MPT NEWS.
JOIN US MONDAY FOR "DIRECT CONNECTION" AND YOUR CHANCE TO ASK THE EXPERTS.
THAT'S MONDAY EVENING LIVE AT 7:00 P.M.
NOW FOR ALL OF US AT MPT THANK YOU FOR WATCHING AND WE'LL SEE YOU BACK HERE MONDAY.
TEST TEST.
CLOSED CAPTIONING BE
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.

New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
State Circle is a local public television program presented by MPT
State Circle is made possible by the generous support of viewers like you.